The pan asian look controversy brought me down memory lane. This is the story of my life. These experiences are somewhat personal but have a political dimension to it, so let me share them with you.

I apologise if I sound as if I am “flaunting” my looks, the truth is I am not. I am really nothing to shout about (flutter flutter). I was born at a time when mixed-marriages were not so popular, where the offsprings would look a little odd (to put it midly) coz  at that time, our names usually do not  match with our skin colors.

It’s either you have the right look or the wrong look, just as you are at the right place or the wrong place. It’s all about timing. Sometimes, no matter how lovely (or handsome) or physically challenged (read: ugly) you are, the skin color you are born with, can either give you fantasies or nightmares.

I had always been mistaken for a Malay,  because of my grandparents, and becauseI spoke like a kampung girl, having grown up with Malay and Indian neighbours – a community of government housing residents at No. 9, Jalan Gambang, Kuantan. My paternal grandpa was Chinese, who married his Sri Lankan neighbour. My mom’s genes, Chinese as they are, were obviously not dominant enough to make me look like an Ah Mooi.

My Malay looks and the little language skills that I had,  proved to be advantages in many instances, for example, in government offices, hospitals, markets, and even with the authorities. But in others, it proved to be disastrous.

During puasa time hawkers refused to sell me food. I had to explain my mixed parentage and my origin before they were convinced. You’re laughing at this, I can tell. But if you were me at that time, feeling hungry or thirsty and just wanting to have a bite at something, anything, you’d be annoyed as hell. 

In school, it proved to be a bad dream. I used to hate home science, especially sewing classes, but since my school at that time did not offer Commerce or other courses of my interest, I was stuck with Sains Rumah Tangga.  I often did not complete my homework, for I was hopeless at the skills.

But judgement day came one day, and those of us who did not submit our homework was called to the front of the class. I found myself among several Malay girls. My teacher then, a Chinese woman, adopted by an Indian family, was quite a racist. “Semua sama bangsa,” (all the same race) she yelled, and told us to go and stand on our chairs as punishment. Kejam-nya! (Cruel).

I tried to challenge my teacher, to tell her that I was ethnically a Chinese, just to make the point that a Chinese could also be a recalcitrant at school work, you know. But she refused to hear me out, and summoned me straight to the chair with the others.

I believe that day was the day I resolved to be a Malaysian, and not Malay, Chinese, Indian or “lain-lain” (others).  Since that day I knew my destiny: I would not do to others what others had done to me.

Time flew but my looks did not diminish. I mean my Malayness just became more obvious. I was secretly happy at the thought as well, because it always made me feel special, noticed and remembered. 

“Your name is Susan? But you look so Malay! We thought you are a Malay!” people would say. It made me smile inside. Happy to have deceived them. Happy also to have been given so much attention. LOL.

In University, this look proved to be advantageous. I was in a competitive course – School of Mass Communications. I was in my first year. There were always countless activities to attend and get involved in – and most of them fun activities. The only problem was one had to compete for it, and compete hard.

Strangely, I got selected for every activity I applied for. My course mates became envious. And one day we marched up to the event organisers and asked this silly question: why is it that Susan always gets to attend whatever she wants?

“Oh, we like to select those who have the Malaysian look,” said the organiser. “We want to promote Muhibbah”.

What???!!!  I dropped “Mass-Comm” in my second year.

By then, I grew up always conscious of my skin color. You see, I am not putih-melepak (snow white), kuning-langsat (yellow-skin) or hitam-manis (black-beauty). I am simply a little brownie. Like the color of peanut butter, you know. ( Yummy). But I liked myself a lot.

I liked myself a lot because I could blend into the crowd, even in the oddest of places. During one of my Ethnography project in Tasek Bera (Pahang) under Dr. Hood Salleh from UKM, I sorta found “my people” (Malay = orang kita), (Chinese Hokkien = kakilang), (Tamil = numberkaran) -  among the Semelais .

A little Semelai girl, whose father was a Chinese contractor who abandoned her mother when she was born, called me Kakak (elder sister). She was very attached to me during my 5-day stay in the village. I asked her “how come”?.

“Because you look like me. We have the same skin color,” she said, with a gentle smile.

In the same University, I was persuaded to join the ‘Gawai‘ (harvesting) dance because I could “pass-off” as a Sabahan. Yet during my first year as a freshie, I was forced to wear the scarf because the seniors said I looked like Malay and shouln’t show a bad example. I followed without protest and was awarded “Pelajar Teladan” (Exemplary Student) at the close of orientation week.

Needless to say, all these episodes only enriched my character and made me feel truly Malaysian. You could say that nothing, and I really mean nothing – not all the crap that comes out from the mouths and actions of politicians and the powers that be – could take these away from me.  

However, a life time of discrimination – positive or otherwise – can be tiresome you know.

These days I am being discriminated for my looks again, and this time I am not happy about it.

In Bangkok, I look so Thai that taxi-men would rather discard me by the road-side and pick up a farang (foreigner) who came later in the queue, though I am standing, soaking wet without an umbrella in the rain.

Why or why must I pay for my looks?

I guess with mentalities like Information Minister “Zam” in the scenes, we don’t have to wonder (or wander) that far.

About these ads

27 Responses »

  1. Winston says:

    With the BN government in power, we will never be truly Malaysians.
    Although it has always been wondering why there is polarisation among the races, its acts have always been to reinforce such a mentality among the people.
    Everything it did, every act it made, is based on race, not whether you are Malaysian. The reason for this is very obvious and that is to concentrate all benefits on one race.
    This has been going on for at least the past quarter century.
    So, with this bunch in power, we will be the same – ad infinitum.

  2. politikus says:

    hear hear! :) i get told that i look like korean. errr, yeay?

    lol.

  3. susan says:

    hey tikus, if you look korean in bangkok, you get first class treatment! lol.

  4. lucia says:

    hey i too had been mistaken as a malay before several times. i thought it is because of my dark skin but my good friend said i have malay features. what are malay features i wonder. (i don’t speak as well as a malay though).

    then i had been mistaken as a filipino and even a thai too. once a stranger in a plane asked me am i a chinese and when i said yes she asked “100% pure chinese?”. i said yes and she said i look like i have mixed blood – either filipino or thai!

    anyway all this mistaken identity had not bought me any problem or embarrassment. in fact i kind of enjoy it. :)

  5. some1 says:

    racism is rampant everywhere. there’s alittle of it in everyone, contrary to what everyone says.

    being passed off as a Malay has its advantages and also its disadvantages. have you ever been cheated by some hawker who thinks you’re Malay and prone to be cheated?

    just love yourself for who you are. you’d stand tall no matter what people do or say about you.

  6. wits0 says:

    Racism that is institutionalized makes the defining difference and differs for this “rampant racism everywhere” sort. There is no moral equivalence eligible for credible usage hence.

  7. d says:

    the minister had nothing better to comment

  8. wits0 says:

    Correction :
    “Racism that is institutionalized makes the defining difference and differs FROM this “rampant racism everywhere” sort.

    BTW, d, the minister is venturing into territories outside his ken. Hamlet might have told him thus:
    “There are more things in heaven and earth, Minister, than are dreamt of in your philosophy.”

  9. susan says:

    some1, yes…i got cheated many times, just that i was too blur (at that moment) to realise it :-(

  10. Rod says:

    Looking at the larger picture…

    In Malaysia, non-Malays are discriminated in policy, and even when implemented, a large minority of Malays fall through the cracks if they’re not part of the political and business elite (or don’t eventually become part of them).

    In Singapore, race-related policies in theory are non-discriminatory, but in the implementation, they obviously favour the Chinese majority.

    *sigh* What a world…

  11. kent says:

    in private sectors and manpowers,
    they are discriminated.
    Where is the unity vision?

  12. wits0 says:

    Here’s the huge list of discrimination in Bolehland which demolishes the common usage of moral equivalence, like by comparision with Singapore, say :

    http://www.worldpress.org/2298.cfm

    Unity is a delusion and an unabashed indulgent inversion in rehashed assertion. Unless, of course one can have the cake and eat it too!

  13. Jermayne says:

    Hi Susan,

    I have been asked questions like “Are u a Chinese?” , “I thought you are a Malay!” and “You sure you are not mixed ar?”practically all my life since entering Primary 1.

    I lost count of how many times i would need to explain to newly introduced friends of my race, ethnicity and utter assuring statements like ‘Yes, i am 100% pure chinese, not mixed.”

    I have often been told that my features (my eyes especially) aren’t typically for a Chinese.Plus, coming from a national school, i speak fluent Malay with the Penang twang like how the Malays speak. And of course, my skin colour must have been the crucial deciding factor as its an active melanin producer. I cannot afford to go under the sun as i will practically turn 2-3 shades darker immediately(even for 1 hour)! And its seems to take eternal for me to regain my fairness once tanned.

    Nevertheless, like what you said – the attention is flattering and makes me feel special. =)

    Also, at workplace, some colleagues called me ‘Susan’ as well as my Chinese name pronounciation sounds like it.

    Anyway, just wanna let you know that this is a great blog!
    Keep it up!=)

  14. VTT says:

    Why dis Zam make such a statement I wonder?

    The Malays look like Indonesians and Vice versa.

    The Chinese looks like errrr well, Chinese

    The Indians and the Mamaks look like again, Indians.

    So, the true Malaysia look would be a mixture of all – ie Pan Malaysian, that represents a broad spectrum of Malaysian.

    the pure Malaysia look would have to go to the real Bumis of Malaysia such as the Asli, the Khadazans etc.

    so why is our information minister so misinformed?

  15. Rikey® says:

    when I was young
    they tot i was japanese
    they tot i was indian
    they tot i was mixed
    they tot i was tony leong also!

    but what i care is how this country will turn out
    not if what COLOR we have!

  16. windypurple says:

    haha! Susan, this post is cool..
    from young, i look like indian. then I look like Kadazan when im in secondary sch. The rest of my days in KL, ppl are unsure what race I am so they concluded that I’m a malay. A sg.wang salesgirl once thought i’m frm hawaii…so she spoke to me in english with wonder…my goodness, she was dissapointed when i reply her with cantonese and said that “i’m a chinese lah..”
    Mayb i shud hv misled her by adding some fake accent…

    all these are contributions on the bright sunny sun who gave me da greatest hitam manis skin, which im trying to whiten.

  17. Rain^Check says:

    “With the BN government in power, we will never be truly Malaysians.”

    Which government do you suggest then? PAS? Keadilan? DAP?

    Unless and until our Opposition decides to sort themselves out, I honestly the only ppl who are even remotely capable of running a complicated country such as Malaysia…

  18. Rikey® says:

    complicated country ?

    it was simple until some politicians made it complicated lor!

  19. sharleen says:

    cool susan …it same goes 2 me…but dont care im malaysian ..wats MALAY??

  20. EDDIE84 says:

    GOT THE SAME STORY AS U GUYS
    PPL THOUGHT I’M CHINESE, THAI, FILIPINO, INDONESIAN, JAPANESE, KOREAN, AND I DON’T KNOW WHY, BUT AN INDIAN MISTOOK ME FOR AN INDIAN ONCE….LOL

    BUT THEN I’M PURE MALAY.
    ‘MALAYSIAN’

  21. Sorry says:

    There are white Klingons and black Klingons. This goes to show that its not just an Earth thing.

  22. bolehbug says:

    Hi
    Browsing on a lazy Sunday
    LinDan defeated Sonny DK, China sapu ladies singles & doubles, Indon take mens doubles,
    MOTOGP on telly, footie later, good sunday telly for couch potatoes.

    Anyway, interesting to hear about Kuantan, left long time already, haven’t been back since graduation.

    You were in MGS huh, monkey girls school…hehe
    with Mrs Quah as HM?
    I was in St Thomas School, slow tortoise school,…

    Not sure if our paths crossed, somehow hooked up more with the girls from SMTA in Form 4/5…hehe

    Debate team on the Jack Chia Shield in SABS??

    Looks, also ended being berated in public by an elderly malay chappie in a kopiah for eating an ice-cream in public in front of the old Pahang Emporium (wonder what is there now), looking back, quite hilarious because didn’t realise that I was his target and continued eating till finally my friend told me that I was probably being mistaken as a Malay…
    First brush with discrimination, or rather memorable life-event, being refused privileges of a Chinese Association, those days they gave prizes to children of members who did well in school… Mother thought good idea to join only to be told that she (mother) being a pure ethnic chinese can join and pay subscription but all the offspring being impure chinese of mixed parentage will not be eligible for any benefits, mother gave them the polite equivalent of a 2-finger salute…haha

    Yeah, looks or how looks are interpreted have been a constant source of amusement and irritation…
    In sec school, had a personal motto, “Accept me as I am, Allow me to learn what I can become” written in textbooks…
    Bittersweet school/childhood memories

    anyway, be nice if can meet up to chat about old times in Kuantan if nothing else

  23. Nice Lim says:

    “Memories brings everyone back to basic”
    ******************************
    Just relax……

  24. Nice Lim says:

    Dear Susan,
    “GOOD HEART IS MORE IMPORTANT THAN GOOD LOOK”
    Thank you for your very wonderful blogs.I can learn lots of things and get to knows lots of wise and friendly cts.Correct me if i am wrong.

  25. wits0 says:

    Voice of Faye Wong. Great anime-mation of Rinoa Heartily.

  26. Nice Lim says:

    Kombanwa and domo arigato gozaimasta wits0 and to all ………

  27. Nice Lim says:

    Looks is not important …..but the HEART is…..

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s